L to R: .308, 260 Remington, 6.5 Creedmoor, 6.5X47 |
When I
ponder the advent of a new cartridge I do so with skepticism. The first thing
that comes to mind is the fact that a new cartridge calls for the production
and sales of new guns that will fire these new ballistic marvels. A current
example of this process is the rage over the “6.5 Creedmoor”. The very name of
the round caught my attention. Creedmoor is a name I associate with antique
weapons that were used on long range targets. However, when I compared the
performance of the new-comer to the .260 Remington and 7mm-08, I found little
difference.
Then I came across an article in Real Guns
magazine that kind of lends credence to my Creedmoor theory. Here’s an excerpt:
The Creedmoor Reference
Product
names often are established to trigger transference; the emotions associated
with something in past memory, hopefully positive, carried over to something
new, prior to acquiring any actual direct experience. A common example of this
is when you meet someone for the first time and feel as though you've known
them for a long time. Frequently this happens because the new acquaintance
shares traits in common with a person you know, or had known, well. Creedmoor
was a great name to Hornady, the designer of the cartridge, to reference. It
was the name of the rifle range opened by the National Rifle Association in
1873 on New York's Long
Island. Creedmoor was host to the famous American - Irish long
range rifle competition held in 1874. Of course, there is also the term
"Creedmoor" applied to a rifle, which is shorthand for parameters
defining rifles used for Creedmoor long range competition. I was surprised to
learn that there was no "Creedmoor", only the family name
"Creed", the people who once owned the range's site and the site's
similarity to the moorland of Great
Britain. The name "6.5 Creedmoor"
instantly evokes a sense of tradition, imagery of long range shooting and
expectations for a high degree of accuracy. Ruger chambered and defined a rifle
fitting for those expectations.
Some
research revealed the acreage purchased from a farmer named Creed was in an area
that could be described as a “moor”; thus, the name Creedmoor was give to the
rifle club
I always
thought a Creedmoor was a specific
make of rifle like a Sharps, but it turns out that that it is a class of long
range, single shot rifles. Hornady Manufacturing’s marketing team apparently
cashed in on this misnomer when they named their, not so unique, cartridge
design.
Sp why the big push for the 6.5 Creedmoor? I
the “Slamfire” said it well on the Firing line Forum: …”gun writers are shills for the industry, paid to write promotional
articles, all of which are geared to raise revenue in one way or another. They
get fully paid “writer symposiums”, plant tours, and fully paid hunting trips.
These hunting trips cost between $5000-$10000 dollars when you cost in time,
food, hotel, guns, gear, and guides. So if in the articles you read, if you see
some poor animal killed by a grinning gun writer you know the article was
financed by an entity with big pockets.”
We may
be reaching a point where there are just too many cartridges available, but we
need to be careful that the anti-gun folks don’t manipulate this statement to
suggest there are too many guns. There ain’t no such thing as too many guns.